| (40.71) | ||||
| 09/05/09 | hosting | Rose-Hulman | (44.54) | 24-61 |
| 09/12/09 | hosting | Manchester | (42.44) | 31-21 |
| 09/19/09 | at | Anderson | (38.68) | 37-34 |
| 10/03/09 | hosting | Wooster | (45.27) | 3-49 |
| 10/10/09 | hosting | Wittenberg | (51.66) | 3-42 |
| 10/17/09 | at | Hiram | (34.87) | 10-7 |
| 10/24/09 | hosting | Oberlin | (39.76) | 13-19 |
| 10/31/09 | hosting | Kenyon | (41.04) | 21-9 |
| 11/07/09 | at | Ohio Wesleyan | (40.88) | 7-20 |
| 11/14/09 | at | Denison | (41.42) | 21-17 |