| 09/03/05 | hosting | McDaniel | 35-36 |
| 09/10/05 | at | Shenandoah | 49-20 |
| 09/17/05 | at | Hanover | 56-42 |
| 10/01/05 | at | Hampden-Sydney | 31-24 |
| 10/15/05 | hosting | Guilford | 62-46 |
| 10/22/05 | at | Emory & Henry | 31-17 |
| 10/29/05 | at | Washington and Lee | 17-13 |
| 11/05/05 | hosting | Randolph-Macon | 53-20 |
| 11/12/05 | hosting | Catholic | 50-30 |
| 11/19/05 | hosting | Wash & Jeff | 30-21 |
| 11/26/05 | at | Thiel | 24-13 |
| 12/03/05 | at | Wesley | 7-46 |